Sign up to the College of Internal Scientific Reviewers

The Temerty Faculty of Medicine is seeking volunteer grant proposal reviewers to enrol in our pilot College of Internal Scientific Reviewers. The College will provide on-campus faculty with scientific peer review of their draft proposals to various competitions (with planned expansions to other competitions once the College is established). An internal peer review system has multiple benefits:

  • It supplements the Office of the Vice Dean, Research & Health Science Education’s existing editorial review services with invaluable scientific feedback from a fellow faculty member;
  • It enhances our collaborative environment by providing researchers with greater awareness of colleagues’ projects across the Faculty; and
  • It provides a larger pool of potential reviewers beyond a single department, introducing critical perspectives and inputs to your draft proposals.

Internal peer review has proven successful in other divisions and institutions and faculty members in Medicine have expressed great interest in accessing such a service. We are truly excited to launched this and strongly hope you’ll consider joining the College.

Why be a Reviewer?

In addition to the reasons above, reviewers of funded proposals will receive a $500 contribution to their unrestricted research account (PI CFC) in recognition of their feedback. Participation as an internal scientific reviewer is also an eligibility requirement for the Faculty’s Pathway Grant

What is Expected of Reviewers?

The review will be a two-step process: 1) abstract review, then 2) full proposal review. Reviewers will be expected to complete each step within one week – please see timelines below. Reviewers will not be asked to review more than two applications for any given competition.

How do I Conduct a Proposal Review?

Reviewers will assess proposals using an internal review rubric,

Can I have my own Proposal Reviewed?

Yes. The College of Peer Reviewers will operate on a quid pro quo basis: if you wish to have your proposal reviewed, you must join the College and be willing to review your peers’ proposals, either in the upcoming competition or future ones.

How do I join the College of Reviewers?

Please enrol below in the College through our online College of Internal Scientific Reviewers

Do I need to sign up to the College each competition?

No, you will remained enrolled each competition unless you contact us that you are unable to review.

How do I submit for review?

Please submit your abstract for CIHR project grant to cindy.faber@utoronto.ca by the abstract submission deadline of February 10, 2022.
Please submit your full application for cindy.faber@utoronto.ca by the full draft proposal deadline of February 24, 2022 by 3:00pm.

2022 Review Timelines

The CIHR Project Grant registration deadline is February 9, 2022.

INTERNAL DEADLINES FOR APPLICANT TO SUBMIT FOR REVIEWER TO SEND BACK
February 10 – Abstract Submission Deadline  
February 17 – Abstract Review Deadline  
February 24 – Full Application Submission Deadline  
March 3 – Full Application Review Deadline (and MRA due)  

The CIHR Project Grant Full Application Deadline is March 9, 2022.

Sign up here to join the College

  • 1 Current Sign up here to join the College
  • 2 Area of Research
  • 3 Statement of Confidentiality
  • 4 Complete